Pen & Stationery Reviews

Archival Ink Guide: Iron Gall, Pigment and ISO 12757-2

By YPen Published

Archival ink is ink whose writing stays legible for decades and does no chemical harm to the paper, and no single label proves both. For pens used on documents, the formal benchmark is the “DOC” designation under ISO 12757-2 for ballpoint pens and ISO 14145-2 for roller ball pens: erasing must visibly damage the paper before the line disappears, and the line must stay visible after ethanol, acid, alkali, bleach, 24 hours in water and a light-fading test. Neither standard covers fountain pens. For those, the options that makers and conservators document are carbon and other pigment inks, an ink such as Rohrer & Klingner’s Dokumentus whose maker cites the ISO 12757-2 resistance requirements, and iron gall ink, which is permanent on the page but in some formulations corrodes the paper.

Quick answer: what “archival” can mean

PropertyWhat it asksWhere it is defined or discussed
LightfastnessDoes the line stay visible after prolonged light exposure?ISO 12757-2 clause 4.8, tested against blue wool references
Water resistanceDoes the line stay visible after soaking?ISO 12757-2 clause 4.7 (24 hours in water)
Chemical resistanceDoes the line survive ethanol, acid, alkali and bleach?ISO 12757-2 clauses 4.3 to 4.6
Alteration resistanceDoes erasing damage the paper before the line disappears?ISO 12757-2 clause 4.2
Chemical stability toward paperDoes the ink itself degrade the sheet over time?Conservation literature on iron gall ink corrosion

The first four rows measure the mark. The last row measures what the mark does to the page, and the documentary-use clauses of the pen standards do not test it. Resistance on the page says nothing about chemical stability: iron gall ink, prized for centuries for its “indelibility”, can still corrode the paper it is written on.

What the document standards actually cover

Two kinds of ISO standard come up when people search for document-proof ink: the documentary-use parts of the pen standards, and ISO 11798 on the permanence of writing on paper. Each is narrower than the label “permanent” suggests.

ISO 12757-2 and ISO 14145-2: pens for documents

ISO 12757-2:1998, Ball point pens and refills, Part 2: Documentary use (DOC), and ISO 14145-2:1998, Roller ball pens and refills, Part 2: Documentary use (DOC), are parallel documents. The introduction to each says documentary use needs requirements beyond general use, to assure the legibility of lettering and for the handling and storage of documents over long periods, requirements it notes are often discussed with the archivist. It gives “the preparation of documents that are required as evidence” as an example of documentary use, and adds that pens meeting the requirements produce lines more resistant to modification, such as attempts to falsify a document. The free previews of both on the iTeh Standards site show the scope, requirement, test and marking clauses; the official texts are sold by ISO and national standards bodies. As of November 2026 both are still in their first, 1998 editions: the catalogue of the Estonian Centre for Standardisation and Accreditation (EVS) lists no later edition of ISO 12757-2 or ISO 14145-2.

The additional requirements, clauses 4.2 to 4.8 of ISO 12757-2, are pass-or-fail checks on a machine-written test line about 5 cm long; clause 4.1 refers back to the general-use requirements of ISO 12757-1.

ClauseRequirementTest described in clause 6.2
4.2Erasure resistance: the paper must show clear damage before the line is rendered invisibleErase part of a line after 10 minutes of drying
4.3Ethanol resistance: line remains visibleImmerse in 50 % aqueous ethanol for 10 minutes
4.4Hydrochloric acid resistanceImmerse in 10 % hydrochloric acid for 24 hours, then rinse
4.5Ammonium hydroxide resistanceImmerse in 10 % ammonium hydroxide for 24 hours, then rinse
4.6Bleaching resistanceImmerse in 3 % chloramin T solution for 5 minutes, then rinse
4.7Water resistanceImmerse in distilled or de-ionized water for 24 hours
4.8Light resistanceExpose alongside blue wool references until the contrast of blue wool reference 5 equals grey scale grade 4

The resistance clauses require only that “the line shall remain visible”. They do not require the colour to stay unchanged, and none of the documentary-use clauses tests whether the ink damages paper. The standard also fixes how a compliant product is designated: the description, “ISO 12757-2”, a refill type code, a tip code and the indicator “DOC”, for example “Ball point refill ISO 12757-2 B B DOC”. Disposable pens or refills are to carry the name of the manufacturer or supplier or a trademark, that designation, and a manufacture date or batch number. ISO 14145-2 sets the same requirement clauses, 4.2 to 4.8, and the same tests for roller ball pens, with designations such as “Roller ball refill ISO 14145-2 B B DOC”.

ISO 12757-2 covers ball point pens, refillable or not, and their refills; ISO 14145-2 covers roller ball pens and refills in the same way. Gel ink ball pens have a separate documentary-use standard, ISO 27668-2:2009. Neither ISO 12757-2 nor ISO 14145-2 covers fountain pens or bottled ink, so a fountain pen ink that cites the ISO 12757-2 resistance requirements (see the maker section below) is applying that standard’s tests to a product outside its scope.

ISO 11798: permanence of writing on paper

ISO 11798:2023, Information and documentation - Permanence and durability of writing, printing and copying on paper - Requirements and test methods, takes a different angle. According to its EVS catalogue entry, it specifies requirements and test methods for the permanence and durability of writing, printing and copying on paper stored in libraries, archives and other protected environments for long periods, where the information must be retained “but not necessarily the full artistic quality”. It applies to images on white permanent paper conforming to ISO 9706 or ISO 11108 and to marks from pens, stamps, copying machines and printers. It does not apply to documents stored under harmful conditions such as high humidity, excessive heat, light, pollutants or the risk of water damage, though the scope adds that resistance to water and light still matters because documents may sit in unprotected places before they reach an archive. It also excludes legal documents, such as banking documents, “where the authenticity is of primary interest”, and documents whose information is affected by small colour changes. The 2023 edition is valid from 2 June 2023, and the catalogue lists ISO 11798:1999 as the earlier edition.

Two practical points follow from the scope. First, the standard assumes permanent paper, which makes paper half of the question; the paper guide for fountain pens covers the sheet side. Second, it treats the mark as part of a stored record and leaves out legal documents where authenticity comes first, which is the evidence use ISO 12757-2 is written for.

Iron gall ink: chemistry, history and the corrosion problem

Iron gall ink is the historic document ink, and the Iron Gall Ink Website notes that “the major part of our historic collections” was made with this “potentially corrosive” ink.

How iron gall ink is made and why it lasted

The Iron Gall Ink Website, presented by the Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands (RCE) since 2011, describes the ink’s main ingredients as tannin, most often extracted from galls, plus iron sulfate (vitriol), gum and water, all inexpensive and readily available. A Library of Congress conservation article describes the most common historical recipes the same way: oak galls were mixed with water to release tannins, which reacted with iron sulfate to form a dark solution, and gum arabic was added to ease the flow from quills and, later, metal-nib pens.

The site’s history page says the earliest documents written in iron gall ink, on papyrus, date to the first centuries after Christ, and that because of its “indelibility” it was “the ink of choice for documentation from the Middle Ages to the twentieth century”. The Library of Congress article calls it the primary writing ink of the Western world from the 12th through the 19th centuries. The site lists official documents such as wills, bookkeeping records, logs and real estate transactions among the objects that carry it, and says good-quality iron gall ink was stable in light and, depending on how it was made, had a deep blue-black, velvety tone.

Why it corrodes paper

The Library of Congress states that iron gall ink “has been used for the last several centuries, and some formulations can be extremely corrosive to documents.” It says the ink can make manuscripts and other documents illegible and inaccessible through loss of text, bleeding, fading, strike-through and acid migration, and that this ink corrosion is very difficult to arrest without further loss or change to the ink’s appearance. The Library began a treatment study in 2002; across eight treatments applied to standardized ink samples on three types of paper, “no single treatment gave superior results for every property examined.” In the Library’s June 2008 Information Bulletin, conservators Sylvia Albro and Julie Biggs explain that historical recipes often held more iron than a balanced chemical formula needed, causing a degradation process that involves two reactions, iron-catalyzed oxidation and acid hydrolysis; affected paper is “acidic, discolored, brittle, and sometimes even riddled with holes.”

The Iron Gall Ink Website’s chemistry page, a 1998 essay by Gerhard Banik, attributes the damage to the oxidizing action of soluble transition metal compounds on cellulose: iron, plus trace elements such as copper and zinc. It reports that by far the strongest effect has proved to be a radical mechanism catalyzed by iron(II) compounds, “even under neutral conditions”, much stronger than the action of acids, and it outlines a proposed radical chain reaction in which Fe2+ reacts with oxygen and the resulting radicals break down cellulose. It cites Neevel’s analyses showing that unbalanced iron gall inks were often used on historical documents and that excess iron(II) sulphate in the ink correlates with ink decay on paper. It concludes that deacidification alone will not stop the decay without removing the soluble transition metal compounds from the paper or at least converting them to chemically inert compounds.

A 2001 condition-rating brochure by Birgit Reissland and Judith Hofenk de Graaff, published by the RCE as ICN-Information number 1, describes ink corrosion as the deterioration of paper or parchment caused by the acids and metal ions present in ink, and rates the severity for each object in one of four categories: good, fair, poor or bad.

How common is the damage?

The conservation sources describe a real problem at archive scale and a mixed picture in individual collections.

SourceWhat it reports
Iron Gall Ink Website, archival collections page (Gerrit de Bruin and Ted Steemers of the National Archive in The Hague, 1998)An estimated 1.5 kilometres of records were suffering severe iron gall ink corrosion; archives from the former Dutch colonies were among the most damaged, partly because of tropical heat and humidity; deterioration progressed at a high rate even in air-conditioned, air-purified repositories
Iron Gall Ink Website, “Ink Corrosion - An autocatalytic nightmare?”Worst-case examples are hard to find, and collections primarily contain artifacts that show no or little sign of ink corrosion
Library of Congress Information Bulletin, June 2008Iron gall ink corrosion “is seen in huge numbers of historical artifacts in museums, archives and libraries around the world”

Both pictures hold at once. Most iron gall writing in collections shows little or no corrosion, while the badly damaged share is large in absolute terms: in 1998, parts of the Dutch National Archive’s collection were already closed to the public “for fear of irreparable damage incurred during handling of fragile papers”. The sources point to the ink formula, the paper and the storage climate as the variables. The same Dutch archivists found the West India Company’s records in generally poorer condition than the East India Company’s, whose rigid rules covered even the making of its ink; a standardized ink “seems to have prevented the use of experimental, unstable ink formulations.”

Modern iron gall inks

Rohrer & Klingner, a German maker of writing inks, says its range of 18 writing-ink tones includes two iron gall inks, that the colours of its iron gall inks intensify as they oxidise in the air, and that “writings with those inks are considered permanent, the historical term being ‘archivally safe’”. That is the maker’s wording about the permanence of the line. It does not address the corrosion mechanism the conservation bodies describe, and none of the sources cited here reports an independent test of a modern iron gall ink on that point. Platinum’s ink guide describes the same oxidation for blue-black ink, in which ferrous ions turn into ferric ions to form the black, and says Platinum is “the only company in the country that continues to manufacture blue-black ink using traditional methods”; it built its Classic Ink around the same trait, writing that changes to black over time. Because the conservation sources tie corrosion to excess iron in the formula, the iron balance in a given bottle is the open question, and the label does not answer it.

Carbon and pigment inks versus dye inks

In a dye ink the colourant is dissolved in the liquid; in a pigment ink it consists of fine solid particles that do not dissolve. Sailor’s FAQ, in its section on the difference between dye and pigment inks, puts it in a maker’s terms: dye ink “has the property of dissolving in water”, is easy to handle, is less prone to problems inside fountain pens and is the basis of many fountain pen inks, but tends to smudge when wet and to fade in light; pigment ink uses pigments that do not dissolve in water and “exhibits superior water resistance and lightfastness compared to dye-based inks”, with less smudging and show-through.

Sailor, a Japanese pen maker, describes its Kiwaguro as a “proprietary super tiny particles pigment ink” designed to minimize clogging and to write as comfortably as a dye-based ink. The product page says it offers minimal bleeding and resists show-through, making it suitable for uses “from illustrations to official documents.”

Platinum’s ink guide says its carbon black ink, made from the pigment carbon black, “does not turn brown due to sunlight, moisture” and is “perfect for permanent storage of records”, whereas its colour inks decolorize with water and turn brown in sunlight. The Carbon Ink product page lists the ink as “Pigmented carbon ink” in a 60 ml bottle.

Pigment water resistance has limits. Sailor’s FAQ says the water resistance of Kiwaguro, Seiboku and Souboku “does not guarantee complete resistance to water”: rain on an envelope addressed in Kiwaguro will not wash the text away, but the wet ink may dissolve and dirty the envelope, because a pigment ink for fountain pens “is designed with some degree of water solubility to ensure ease of cleaning and minimize issues during drying.” The FAQ adds that the type of paper can significantly influence the water resistance of the strokes.

How makers describe document and archival inks

Each entry below is the maker’s own wording, from its own page.

Maker and productThe maker’s wordingWhat it addresses
Rohrer & Klingner, Dokumentus”the world’s first fountain pen ink conforming to the resistance requirements of DIN ISO 12757-2”; says the ink was tested by the Papiertechnische Stiftung Heidenau, “an independent standards body which has certified that this ink can be used by registrars for official documents”; calls it a “pH-adjusted ink” that “guarantees permanent and archival writing”Resistance tests plus pH, from the maker’s page
Rohrer & Klingner, iron gall writing inksIron gall colours intensify on oxidation and writings are “considered permanent, the historical term being ‘archivally safe‘“Line permanence, per the maker
Sailor, Kiwaguro”Proprietary super tiny particles pigment ink”; “suitable for a wide range of uses from illustrations to official documents”; FAQ states water resistance is not completePigment, with a stated limit
Platinum, Carbon Ink”Pigmented carbon ink”; the ink guide says carbon black does not turn brown from sunlight or moisturePigment, light and moisture
Platinum, Classic InkThe ink guide calls it a water-based dye ink with “a vivid dye color at the beginning of writing” whose handwriting “turns black over time” and “has water resistance and long-term storage”Dye ink that darkens over time, described alongside Platinum’s traditional blue-black method

Dokumentus is the one product here whose maker ties its claim to the ISO text and a named testing body. Its wording, conformity with “the resistance requirements” of DIN ISO 12757-2, applies a ballpoint standard’s tests to a fountain pen ink, and its pH adjustment concerns acidity, a factor in paper damage that the pen standards do not test.

Choosing ink for signing, journals and long-term records

Each use below is matched to what the standards, conservators and makers cited above document.

UseWhat the sources supportPractical reading
Signing documents that others will receiveISO 12757-2 (ballpoint) and ISO 14145-2 (roller ball) require lines that resist erasure, ethanol, acid, alkali, bleach, water and light, with a designation ending in DOC; gel ink ball pens have their own standard, ISO 27668-2A ballpoint or roller ball pen or refill marked with that designation carries its maker’s statement of compliance; for gel pens, look for ISO 27668-2. The receiving party’s own rules decide what is accepted
Fountain pen signaturesDokumentus cites the ISO 12757-2 resistance requirements and a named test body; makers describe pigment inks as more water-resistant and lightfast than dye inks, with limitsCheck the maker’s own page for the claim and its test body before relying on it
Journals and diariesMakers describe pigment and carbon inks as resisting light and moisture; iron gall writing is historically permanent, but some formulations corrode paperA carbon or other pigment ink is the documented choice, with the pen-care notes below. The fountain pen ink guide covers dye inks and their trade-offs
Records that must outlast the writerISO 11798 assumes permanent paper and protected storage; conservators warn about iron gall corrosionPair a pigment or tested ink with permanent paper, and store away from light, damp and heat

For journals specifically, see how to start journaling; for pen selection in general, the fountain pen guide.

Pen care for permanent inks

The makers’ care notes all concern ink drying in the pen. Rohrer & Klingner’s Dokumentus page asks that the cap be replaced after use “to prevent blockages in the nib” and says that beyond this no special care is needed. Platinum’s guide warns of its carbon black ink that “since it is not aqueous, it will not discolor once dried, so be careful when using it.” Sailor designs Kiwaguro to minimize clogging, and its FAQ says that when ink does not flow, the nib is in many cases clogged by ink components that have hardened through drying or by foreign matter, and advises cleaning the pen.

Reading a label

Label wordingWhat it can meanWhat to look for
”Archival”Anything from pH-adjusted to “permanent” in the historical senseA named standard or a maker’s description of what was tested
”Permanent”The line survives water or light, possibly only oneWhich property, and the maker’s own conditions
”Document ink”A maker’s term unless a standard is namedA reference such as ISO 12757-2, with the clauses named
”Waterproof”Often “water resistant”Sailor’s FAQ shows a maker stating the limit openly
”Iron gall”Historic chemistryThe maker’s statement about iron balance, which the corrosion literature treats as central

Sources